Posts

Showing posts from November, 2026

What happens if we replace light with sound in Einstein's 2nd postulate ?

  GEMINI:  If you take Postulate 1 (the principle of relativity: the laws of physics take the same form in all inertial frames) and apply Postulate 2 (in its original 1905 form: a wave propagates with a definite speed $v_s$ , independent of the motion of the source) to sound —pushing the hypothesis all the way, i.e., requiring the speed of sound to be the same $v_s$ in every inertial frame—you get a very precise mathematical result, but a direct conflict with the physics of material media. 1. What happens at the level of equations (an "acoustic relativity") If you simultaneously impose: The invariance of the speed of sound $v_s$ across all inertial frames, and The equivalence of inertial frames (the principle of relativity), then the classical Galilean transformations can no longer keep $v_s$ constant. In their place emerges a mathematical structure identical to the Lorentz transformations, but with the speed of light $c$ replaced by the speed of sound $v_s$ : $$\gam...